For most musicians, scoring a major label record deal is at the top of their to-do list, and for good reason. Having one of the Big Four labels (actually three now) working on your music can be your ticket to success. Back in the day, Jerry Wexler’s Atlanta records had amazing success launching artists like Otis Redding, Ray Charles, Aretha Franklin, Led Zepplin, to name just a few.   Many of the other majors like Sony were the only game in town.

But in today’s volatile music industry, there is a downside to being on a major label roster.   Many artists are signed but never record, some record but are never released, some are released with no real push or backing by the company and many flop and are dropped by the labels, even though they may have sales in the hundreds of thousands.

The last estimate I recently saw said that an artist that goes Gold (sales of 500,000) stands to make only around $47,000, This is why so many major artists are choosing not to resign with their record companies, but instead, to release their new CDs independently. An independent artist selling 10,000 of their own CDs can theoretically make twice the amount of money as the signed artist selling 500,000 copies. Of course there are exceptions to this, but selling records alone is not going to sustain an artist’s career in today’s world whether you are on a major label or Indie.

To be objective, the following is probably a fair break-down when you compare the major with the Indies today:

Major Label Deals – The Pros:

  • Money: Deep pockets have to be at the top of any major label “pros” list. Even with major label music sales declining and the industry as a whole struggling to keep up with changes in the way people purchase and listen to music, major labels still have a huge financial advantage over just about every indie label. When your label has a lot of money, that means they’ll be able to spend a lot of money promoting your record – which is exactly what you want. It also means they may be able to offer you a large advance and invest a lot in recording, touring, video shoots and other opportunities for you, although advances are almost a thing of the past.
  • Connections: Money helps open a lot of doors, and when a major label comes knocking, most media outlets are ready to let them in. Additionally, most major labels have been in the business for decades and have long established connections that help you reach your music career goals.
  • Market share can matter when it comes to record labels. Major labels are behind the vast majority of music sold, and this scale of operations can bring many advantages. First, they can get the best deals on manufacturing, advertising and other expenses since they do business in such enormous bulk – they have way more purchasing power than indie labels. Second, because of all of the artists on their roster, they can pull some pretty big strings in the media. Here’s a VERY common scenario: a major label may call up a big music magazine and say, “hey, if you want to interview (insert mega selling artist), we suggest you review/feature (insert brand new, unknown label signing).” This is great for you, if you’re that new label signing, because you get instant press in all of the top spots, giving you maximum exposure overnight.

Major Label Deals – The Cons:

  • Big Pond, Small Fish: A lot of major labels tend to sign a lot of musicians and throw out a lot of music, just to see what will stick. As a new signing, except in very special circumstances, you’re likely to find yourself fighting for attention from the label. If you’re music doesn’t start sticking – read: selling – pronto – then you can find yourself with a record out that isn’t getting much promotion and a label that doesn’t return your phone calls.
  • Continuity: A big part of avoiding the aforementioned “big pond, small fish” syndrome is having a big fan at the label. Usually, this is the person who signed you. However, turn over at a major label can be pretty high – especially in this day and age – and you run a high risk of waking up one day to find out that the person who loved your music is no longer working at the label. The new person who takes over your album may not be such a big fan, and suddenly, no one is too interested in making your album a priority. You can include a “key man” clause in your contract to try to avoid this, but often the bargaining power is against you when you sign a major label deal, so scoring this set up is not guaranteed.
  • Artist Unfriendly Deals: Not every major label deal is unfriendly to the artist, but many of them are set up so that if a cashier accidentally gives you an extra dollar in change, you have to pay the label 50 cents. OK, maybe that’s an exaggeration, but many major labels want to sign artist for multi album deals that offer them very little flexibility and that hand over a lot of creative control to the label. They know all of the loopholes, they want a piece of everything, and they have better lawyers than you.
  • The Passion Question: Many dedicated music lovers work on the major label side of the music industry. However – not everyone who works at major labels love music. You’ll find a higher concentration of people who are in the business strictly for the money in major labels than you will at indie labels, and that often ends up rubbing musicians the wrong way.

Indie Record Deals – The Pros:

  • Respect for Your Music: Indie labels generally have the freedom to work with whomever they like.  There’s no pressure like you’d find at major labels to sacrifice your tastes in favor of seeking chart success. When you get signed to an indie label, in almost every instance it’s because the label is a huge fan of your music; that translates into dedication because they believe in what you’re doing.
  • Close Working Relationships: Because indie labels have smaller staffs and tighter rosters, it’s easier for musicians to develop a close relationship with the people working on their record. Although it’s not always the case that artists can pick up the phone and get an immediate answer, the odds of closer communication are great than they are with a major label.
  • Artist-Friendly Deals: Some larger indie labels have relatively complex contracts, but smaller indies often do business on little more than a handshake and a profit split agreement. You seldom find indie labels demanding any measure of creative control over their artists, and most indies don’t lock their artists into long-term, multi-album contracts.

Indie Label Deals – Cons:

  • Money: While money is the top reason to sign with a major label, it definitely tops the list of negatives for indies. While some indie labels are sitting pretty financially, most small operations are just trying to stay afloat. That means they usually don’t have the coffers to fund an all out media blitz like the majors and they often have to get creative with promotion ideas. They also can’t afford big advances, fancy packaging, large recording budgets, tour support and other pretty perks a major can charm you with. With indie labels, you’ll usually have to remain financially invested in your own music career.
  • Disorganization: Not every indie label is disorganized, but the informal nature of operations at many smaller indie labels means some elements can get a tad bit confusing. For you an artist, they might find that sometimes details may slip through the crack, or it may be hard to figure out  processes that aren’t quite formalized, like accounting, for instance.
  • Market share: The market share factor is on the “pro” list for signing with a major labor. Although the intimate size of indie labels have their upside in terms of closer and more accessible relationships, there is also a downside. They don’t have the purchasing power of major labels, and with a small roster, they have fewer strings to pull with the press.

Again, the majors had their day, they broke a lot of great artists like Otis Redding who was, unfortunately killed in a plane crash Dec. 10, 1967 at the height of his career – 3 days after recording “Dock of the Bay” for Stax & Atlantic records.   He was 26 years old. Jerry Wexler (Atlantic Records)  delivered the eulogy at his funeral.  His song was the first posthumous single to top the charts in the US.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *